Our Menu
Traditional Toppings $0.75 | Specialty Toppings $1.00
Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness. NYPP cannot ensure items do not contain ingredients that might cause an allergic reaction.
Specials
Half sandwich served with a cup of soup OR side house or Caesar salad. Includes soda.
Includes soda
Appetizers
House-made served with ricotta, Pecorino Romano, crostini, and marinara.
Fried risotto bites, ground beef, peas, mozzarella, Pecorino Romano, and marinara.
Toasted ciabatta, tomato, red onions, basil pesto, burrata, and balsamic glaze.
Served with Pomodoro or Fra Diavolo.
Sautéed in garlic, white wine, Pomodoro, or Fra Diavolo.
Served with fried zucchini. Pomodoro, or Fra Diavolo.
Flash-fried, tomato, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, basil, balsamic glaze.
Baked in white wine, lemon, and Italian breadcrumbs.
Garlic butter, Pecorino Romano, EVOO, served with marinara • Add Mozzarella +$2.00
Drizzled with EVOO and fresh lemon juice.
Flash-fried, served with marinara sauce.
Crispy, golden mozzarella sandwich flash-fried, with marinara.
Chilled Salad of Shrimp, calamari, octopus & celery, marinated in lemon and EVOO.
Stuffed with ricotta, topped with mozzarella, marinara, and Pecorino Romano.
Littleneck clams baked in white wine, lemon, and Italian breadcrumbs.
Choice of House Garlic Parmesan, BBQ, Sweet Chili, or Hot Sauce: Ranch or Bleu Cheese Dressing.
Soup & Salads
Dressings served on the side.
Add: Chicken +$6.00 | Shrimp +$9.00 | Salmon +$12.00
Tortellini Meatball or Soup of the Day
Artisan greens, black olives, heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, red onions, olive balsamic vinaigrette.
Romaine, croutons, Pecorino Romano, Parmigiano Reggiano, Caesar dressing.
Iceberg lettuce, crispy bacon, heirloom tomatoes, crispy onions, bleu cheese, white balsamic, and blue cheese dressing.
Romaine, soppressata, mortadella, prosciutto cotto, fresh mozzarella, provolone, chickpeas, kalamata olives, heirloom tomatoes, red onions, parmigiano reggiano, house dressing.
Arugula, grilled chicken, avocado, heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, basil, lemon herb vinaigrette.
Blackened or grilled, iceberg romaine mix, black olives, heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, chickpeas, lemon herb vinaigrette.
Artisan greens, blackened shrimp, strawberries, red onions, walnuts, dried cranberries, feta cheese, and raspberry vinaigrette.
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, EVOO, pesto, balsamic glaze.
Romaine, grilled artichoke, heirloom tomatoes, black olives, fresh mozzarella, lemon herb vinaigrette.
Sandwiches
Served with Homemade Chips or Fries. All heroes served on Brooklyn bread.
Oven-roasted turkey, applewood smoked bacon, tomatoes, spring mix, smashed avocado, dijon mustard, garlic aioli, and sourdough.
Ham, fresh mozzarella, basil, sun-dried tomatoes, EVOO.
Mortadella with pistachio imported from Italy, tomato, artisan lettuce, stracciatella cheese, provolone, pesto.
Ham, soppressata, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, EVOO.
Prosciutto di Parma, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic, EVOO.
Bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, pesto mayo, and sourdough.
Hot Heros
Choice of Eggplant, Chicken, or Meatball.
Oven-roasted Italian sausage, grilled onions, and peppers.
Grilled onions, mushrooms, green peppers, and American cheese.
Romaine, Pecorino Romano, croutons.
Grilled or Fried, romaine, red onions, tomatoes, celery, gorgonzola.
Dried-aged chuck, brisket, short rib blend, yellow American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, signature sauce.
Entrées
Served with Spaghetti, Penne, or Seasonal Vegetables & potatoes.
Different sauce for pasta +$4.00 | Add Soup or Salad +$4.00
Stuffed with ham & mozzarella, served in white wine sauce.
Lightly egg-battered and sautéed in white wine, lemon butter sauce.
Lightly egg-battered and sautéed in white wine, lemon butter sauce.
Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.
Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.
Baked with marinara and melted mozzarella.
Baked with marinara and melted mozzarella.
Baked with marinara and melted mozzarella.
Arugula, cherry tomato, red onions, shaved Pecorino Romano.
Arugula, cherry tomato, red onions, shaved Pecorino Romano.
Arugula, cherry tomato, red onions, shaved Pecorino Romano.
Prosciutto, provolone, spinach, and marsala wine sauce.
Whole butterflied branzino (Mediterranean sea bass) served oreganata, broiled, or pan-seared in a white wine sauce.
Honey garlic salmon, served with saffron rice and the chef’s mixed vegetables. Grilled or Blackened.
Served Francese, Piccata, or Oreganata Style.
Signature Pastas
Choice of Chicken, Meatball, or Sausage.
Peas and mushrooms, in a creamy Alfredo sauce.
Signature vodka sauce.
Stuffed with ricotta, served in marinara.
Slow-cooked beef ragu in our house-made tomato sauce.
Signature marinara sauce.
Zucchini, bell peppers, carrots, broccoli, in our white wine sauce or pomodoro sauce.
(Allow 15 min)
• Baked Ziti
• Papa Joe’s Lasagna
New-York Style Pizza
Traditional or Extra-Thin Crust. All pizzas are cooked slightly well-done.
Small 12” $15.00 | Large 16” $20.00
12" Gluten Free Cauliflower $23
Add Garlic Crust $2.00
12” $2.50 each | 16” $3.00 each
Pepperoni, Bacon, Banana Peppers, Basil, Black Olives, Eggplant, Extra Cheese, Garlic, Green Peppers, Ham, Jalapeños, Meatballs, Mushrooms, Onions, Pineapple, Sausage, Tomatoes.
12” $3.00 each | 16” $4.00 each
Anchovies, Artichoke, Arugula, Capers, Fresh Mozzarella, Green Olives, Kalamata Olives, Pepperoncini, Pesto, Prosciutto, Roasted Red Peppers, Sun-dried Tomatoes, Soppressata, Spinach, or Ricotta.
Specialty Pizzas
12" Gluten Free Cauliflower $23
12" $25.00 | 16" $30.00
Mozzarella, garlic butter, white wine, lemon sauce.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Pepperoni, burrata cheese, basil, Pecorino Romano, and hot honey.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
Pomodoro garlic sauce with fresh mozzarella layered underneath, Pecorino Romano, and pesto.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and Pecorino Romano.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Ham, pepperoni, meatballs, sausage.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Pepperoni, sausage, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Buffalo, BBQ, or Parmigiana style.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
No sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, provolone, Pecorino Romano.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Ham, artichokes, black olives, mushrooms.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Meatballs, onions, ricotta.
12" $22.00 | 16" $26.00
Green peppers, mushrooms, onions, black olives.
12" $22.00 | 16" $26.00
No sauce, American, mozzarella, onions, peppers, mushrooms.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
Fresh Mozzarella, pizza sauce, basil, EVOO, Pecorino-Romano.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
No sauce, mozzarella, tomatoes, light fresh mozzarella, basil, EVOO.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
Mozzarella, Alfredo sauce, grilled chicken, bacon.
New York-Style Deep Dish
Traditional Toppings 12" $3.00 each | 16" $3.50 each
Specialty Toppings 12" $3.50 each | 16" $4.50 each
12" $20.00 | 16" $26.00
New York deep dish style
12" $20.00 | 16" $26.00
Thin square crust with pizza sauce, mozzarella, garlic, and oregano finished with basil and Pecorino-Romano.
12" $20.00 | 16" $26.00
Pizza sauce with mozzarella layered underneath finished with Pecorino-Romano and EVOO.
Calzones & Strombolis
Served with a side of marinara.
Stuffed with mozzarella, ricotta, and Pecorino Romano.
Mozzarella and one traditional topping.
Crispy chicken cutlet, marinara, and mozzarella.
Sautéed sausage, bell peppers, onions, and mozzarella.
Ham, soppressata, pepperoni, mozzarella.
Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness. NYPP cannot ensure items do not contain ingredients that might cause an allergic reaction.
Appetizers
House-made served with ricotta, Pecorino Romano, crostini, and marinara.
Fried risotto bites, ground beef, peas, mozzarella, Pecorino Romano, served with marinara.
Toasted ciabatta, tomato, red onions, basil pesto, burrata, and balsamic glaze.
Served with Pomodoro or Fra Diavolo.
Sautéed in garlic, white wine, Pomodoro, or Fra Diavolo.
Served with fried zucchini, Pomodoro, or Fra Diavolo.
Flash-fried, tomato, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, basil, balsamic glaze.
Baked in white wine, lemon, and Italian breadcrumbs.
Garlic butter, Pecorino Romano, EVOO, served with marinara • Add Mozzarella +$2.00
Drizzled with EVOO and fresh lemon juice.
Flash-fried, served with marinara sauce.
Crispy, golden mozzarella sandwich flash-fried and served with marinara.
Chilled salad of shrimp, calamari, octopus & celery, marinated in lemon and EVOO.
Stuffed with ricotta, topped with mozzarella, marinara, and Pecorino Romano.
Littleneck clams baked in white wine, lemon, and Italian breadcrumbs.
Choice of House Garlic Parmesan, BBQ, Sweet Chili, or Hot Sauce: Ranch or Bleu Cheese Dressing.
Salads
Dressings served on the side.
Add: Chicken +$6.00 | Shrimp +$9.00 | Salmon +$12.00
Artisan greens, black olives, heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, red onions, white balsamic vinaigrette.
Romaine, croutons, Pecorino Romano, parmigiano reggiano, Caesar dressing.
Iceberg lettuce, crispy bacon, heirloom tomatoes, crispy onions, bleu cheese, white balsamic, and blue cheese dressing.
Romaine, soppressata, mortadella, prosciutto cotto, fresh mozzarella, provolone, chickpeas, kalamata olives, heirloom tomatoes, red onions, parmigiano reggiano, house dressing.
Arugula, grilled chicken, avocado, heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, basil, lemon herb vinaigrette.
Blackened or Grilled, iceberg romaine mix, black olives, heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, chickpeas, lemon herb vinaigrette.
Artisan greens, blackened shrimp, strawberries, red onions, walnuts, dried cranberries, feta cheese, and raspberry vinaigrette.
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, EVOO, pesto, balsamic glaze.
Romaine, grilled artichoke, heirloom tomatoes, black olives, fresh mozzarella, lemon herb vinaigrette.
Signature Pastas
Al dente made to order. Finished with Pecorino Romano.
Gluten-free or Gnocchi +$3.00
Add: Chicken +$6.00 | Shrimp +$9.00 | Salmon +$12.00 • Add Soup or Salad +$4.00
Ground beef, ricotta, mozzarella, and marinara sauce.
Cream sauce, pancetta, egg, and Pecorino Romano.
Signature vodka sauce, topped with crispy chicken cutlets.
Fresh pasta, slow-cooked beef ragù in our house-made tomato sauce.
Grilled chicken, peas, and mushrooms in a creamy Alfredo sauce.
Garlic-butter shrimp tossed in white wine lemon sauce.
Zucchini, bell peppers, carrots, and broccoli in a White Wine Sauce or Pomodoro.
Baked pasta filled with ricotta, topped with mozzarella, in a marinara sauce.
Tossed in basil pesto, grilled chicken, and topped with burrata.
Signature vodka sauce.
House-made meatballs in our marinara sauce.
Stuffed with ricotta, served in marinara.
Linguine with shrimp, mussels, clams & calamari in White Wine, Pomodoro, or Fra Diavolo.
Littleneck and chopped baby clams in White Wine, Pomodoro, or Fra Diavolo Sauce.
Entrées
Served with Spaghetti, Penne, or Seasonal Vegetables & potatoes.
Different sauce for pasta +$4.00 | Add Soup or Salad +$4.00
Stuffed with ham & mozzarella, served in a white wine sauce.
Lightly egg-battered and sautéed in white wine, lemon butter sauce.
Lightly egg-battered and sautéed in white wine, lemon butter sauce.
Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.
Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.
Baked with marinara and melted mozzarella.
Baked with marinara and melted mozzarella.
Baked with marinara and melted mozzarella.
Arugula, cherry tomato, red onions, shaved Pecorino Romano.
Arugula, cherry tomato, red onions, shaved Pecorino Romano.
Arugula, cherry tomato, red onions, shaved Pecorino Romano.
Prosciutto, provolone, spinach, and marsala wine sauce.
Whole butterflied branzino (Mediterranean sea bass) served oreganata, Broiled, or Pan-Seared in a white wine sauce.
Honey garlic salmon, served with saffron rice and the chef's mixed vegetables, Grilled or Blackened.
Served Francese, Piccata, or Oreganata-Style.
Baked in white wine, lemon, and Italian breadcrumbs.
Dried-aged chuck, brisket, short rib blend, yellow American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, signature sauce.
Served only with Straight Fries, Curly Fries, or House-Made Chips.
Only available Sunday after 3 PM
Beef ribs, neck bones, pork spare ribs, homemade meatballs, and Italian sausage — all slow-cooked to perfection.
New York-Style Pizza
Traditional or Extra-Thin Crust. All pizzas are cooked slightly well-done.
Small 12” $15.00 | Large 16” $20.00
12" Gluten Free Cauliflower $23
Add Garlic Crust $2.00
12” $2.50 each | 16” $3.00 each
Pepperoni, Bacon, Banana Peppers, Basil, Black Olives, Eggplant, Extra Cheese, Garlic, Green Peppers, Ham, Jalapeños, Meatballs, Mushrooms, Onions, Pineapple, Sausage, Tomatoes.
12” $3.00 each | 16” $4.00 each
Anchovies, Artichoke, Arugula, Capers, Fresh Mozzarella, Green Olives, Kalamata Olives, Pepperoncini, Pesto, Prosciutto, Roasted Red Peppers, Sun-dried Tomatoes, Soppressata, Spinach, or Ricotta.
Specialty Pizzas
12" Gluten Free Cauliflower $23
12" $25.00 | 16" $30.00
Mozzarella, garlic butter, white wine, lemon sauce.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Pepperoni, burrata cheese, basil, Pecorino Romano, and hot honey.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
Pomodoro garlic sauce with fresh mozzarella layered underneath, Pecorino Romano, and pesto.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and Pecorino Romano.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Ham, pepperoni, meatballs, sausage.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Pepperoni, sausage, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Buffalo, BBQ, or Parmigiana style.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
No sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, provolone, Pecorino Romano.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Ham, artichokes, black olives, mushrooms.
12" $22.00 | 16" $27.00
Meatballs, onions, ricotta.
12" $22.00 | 16" $26.00
Green peppers, mushrooms, onions, black olives.
12" $22.00 | 16" $26.00
No sauce, American, mozzarella, onions, peppers, mushrooms.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
Fresh Mozzarella, pizza sauce, basil, EVOO, Pecorino-Romano.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
No sauce, mozzarella, tomatoes, light fresh mozzarella, basil, EVOO.
12" $21.00 | 16" $25.00
Mozzarella, Alfredo sauce, grilled chicken, bacon.
New York-Style Deep Dish
Traditional Toppings 12" $3.00 each | 16" $3.50 each
Specialty Toppings 12" $3.50 each | 16" $4.50 each
12" $20.00 | 16" $26.00
New York deep dish style
12" $20.00 | 16" $26.00
Thin square crust with pizza sauce, mozzarella, garlic, and oregano finished with basil and pecorino-romano.
12" $20.00 | 16" $26.00
Pizza sauce with mozzarella layered underneath finished with Pecorino-Romano and EVOO.
Calzones & Strombolis
Served with a side of marinara.
Stuffed with mozzarella, ricotta, and Pecorino Romano.
Mozzarella and one traditional topping.
Crispy chicken cutlet, marinara, and mozzarella.
Sautéed sausage, bell peppers, onions, and mozzarella.
Ham, soppressata, pepperoni, mozzarella.
Sides
Disposable chafing rack setup $20.00 (2 half trays or 1 full tray per setup)
Appetizers
ALL Appetizers are half trays
Order 3 trays and get a free House or Caesar Salad
Pastas
Serves 10–12 (Half Tray) | Serves 20–22 (Full Tray)
Eggplant
Serves 10–12 (Half Tray) | Serves 20–22 (Full Tray)
Chicken
Serves 10–12 (Half Tray) | Serves 20–22 (Full Tray)
Veal
Serves 10–12 (Half Tray) | Serves 20–22 (Full Tray)
Seafood
Serves 10–12 (Half Tray) | Serves 20–22 (Full Tray)
Beef & Pork
Serves 10–12 (Half Tray) | Serves 20–22 (Full Tray)
Vegetables
Serves 10–12 (Half Tray) | Serves 20–22 (Full Tray)
Salads
Serves 10–12 Medium Bowl | Serves 20–22 Large Bowl
Add Chicken - Half Tray +$25 | Full Tray +$45
Romaine, grilled artichoke, heirloom tomatoes, black olives, fresh mozzarella, lemon herb vinaigrette.
Arugula, grilled chicken, avocado, heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, basil, lemon herb vinaigrette.
Artisan greens, blackened shrimp, strawberries, red onion, walnuts, dried cranberries, feta cheese, raspberry vinaigrette.
Romaine, soppressata, mortadella, prosciutto cotto, fresh mozzarella, provolone, chickpeas, Kalamata olives, heirloom tomatoes, red onion, Parmigiano Reggiano, house dressing.
Iceberg lettuce, crispy bacon, heirloom tomatoes, crispy onions, bleu cheese, and white balsamic bleu cheese dressing.
Artisan greens, black olives, heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, shaved asiago vinaigrette.
Blackened or grilled, iceberg romaine mix, black olives, heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, chickpeas, lemon herb vinaigrette.
Romaine croutons, Pecorino Romano, Parmigiano Reggiano, Caesar dressing.
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, EVOO, pesto, balsamic glaze.
Brooklyn Heros by The Foot
3 FT serves 10–12, all heroes come pre-cut
Mortadella, soppressata, prosciutto, provolone, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, balsamic dressing.
Ham, turkey, American, lettuce, tomato, oil & vinegar, spices.
Roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella.
Fried chicken cutlet, vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella.
Sweet sausage mixed with bell peppers & onions.
Combo Packages
1. 2 FT Chicken Cutlet Hero grilled or fried with roasted red peppers & fresh mozzarella, basil aioli
2. Half Tray Baked Ziti
3. Half Tray House or Caesar Salad
1. 2 FT Italian Hero or 2 FT Chicken Cutlet Hero grilled or fried with roasted red peppers & fresh mozzarella, basil aioli
2. Half Tray Baked Ziti or Half Tray Penne Vodka
3. Half Tray Sausage & Peppers
4. Half Tray House or Caesar Salad
1. 4 FT Italian, American, or Chicken Cutlet Hero Grilled or Fried
2. Full Tray Penne Vodka or Baked Ziti
3. Full Tray Chicken Francese or Sausage & Peppers
1. 6 FT Italian, American, or Chicken Cutlet Hero Grilled or Fried
2. 1 tray (50) Chicken Wings, choice of sauce
3. Full Tray Penne Vodka or Baked Ziti
4. Full Tray Sausage & Peppers
5. Full Tray House or Caesar Salad
Sandwich & Wraps Platters
Serves 10–12
Mortadella, soppressata, prosciutto, provolone, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato.
Ham, turkey, American cheese, lettuce, tomato.
Romaine, Pecorino Romano, croutons, Caesar dressing.
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato.
Yellowfin tuna, celery, lettuce, tomato.
Romaine, Pecorino Romano, croutons, Caesar dressing.
Grilled or fried chicken, bacon, romaine, red onions, tomato, celery, and gorgonzola.
Dessert Platters
Half Tray | Full Tray